Free Speech Union Logo
March 22, 2025

10 fights to keep free speech free


More often than not, when we contact you, it's about a single pressing issue we're tackling. But our team deals with dozens of smaller items every month too, each one helping us take small steps towards defending and expanding the most basic freedom - the right to speak. 

 

Briefly, here are 6 things we've been doing in the background this week. 

 

1. Instructions to Health NZ: Censorship or not? 

When we saw Health NZ had instructed doctors that they couldn't publicly comment on health issues in their regions without sign-off from the national bureaucracy, we were concerned and immediately contacted the Director of Public Health, who was allegedly behind the instruction. 

 

When asked to comment on the issue for Stuff's Three News, our CEO contacted the advisor to the Minister of Health, to check what the story is. The Minister of Health himself called back directly to clarify that this instruction doesn't limit doctors generally, it limits public servants (some of whom are doctors) from submitting in local forums as public servants in ways that opposes the Government's policy agenda. It doesn't limit free and frank advice to the Government, and they're allowed to submit in their personal capacities, still contributing their expertise. 

 

Good thing we confirmed. It was also handy to get this comment on the record for the former-Minister of Health: 

 

2. Breach of Contract: suing venues that de-platform  

 

We are grateful to the over 12,500 Kiwis who have donated money to the Free Speech Union since we set up almost four years ago. And we aim to steward this investment wisely. That's why, when B:Hive, a venue in Auckland that was going to host the first event of the James Lindsay tour cancelled on us 2 working days out from the event because a single individual had contacted them, we needed to hold them to task.  

 

We accept that private venues can choose not to do business with us. But they can't choose to do business with us, take our payment in full, and then cancel two working days out without expecting us to take them to task for breaching their contract.

 

We insisted B:Hive pay any additional costs for the new venue we used, and they even threw a bit more in on top for the extra hours our staff had to work.  

 

Working to hold venues to account and getting value for our donors money at the same time 💪

 

3. De-banking letter 

 

Talking about money, the issue of de-banking continues to grow. Internationally, numerous major examples (such as with the FSU UK, and also with UK politician Nigel Farage) show what can happen when banks decide, because of what you think and say, they won't do business with you.  

 

That's why we've contacted seven of New Zealand's banks, asking them to outline what their policies are, and what criteria exist for whether they would ever refuse to work with individuals with unorthodox views. 

 

We are still waiting on several responses, but ASB has started on a good note. In an otherwise entirely pro-forma response, the ASB Senior Customer Care Manager told us that they are "committed to ensuring the safe, secure and responsible delivery of banking services".  

 

To which we promptly replied, what does 'safe' banking services mean? Especially if it's somehow different to 'secure' and 'responsible'. Our concern is that it's a 'filler term', really used as an 'anything we don't like' clause. Of course, banks won't part ways with customers too easily - they're there to make money.

 

But when it comes to such a critical service as banking, especially when we have such a concentration of banks that there's little competition, denying banking services because you don't like their opinions or what they say mustn't be permitted.  

 

We'll keep working on this, and make sure the banks know there's someone watching. 😎

 

4. Local Council censors socials 

 

In our experience, local councils rarely respect ratepayers' speech rights in the way they should, but the Far North District Council has recently taken the cake!  

 

Moko Tepania, Far North Mayor, claimed that “people challenging some of the decisions we [FNDC] make” and “letting us know their thoughts” was fine. However, he 

also stated that certain feedback was “racist,” and, in response, noted: “We’re just blocking them now. We’re not going to stand for it if you’re going to be racist or rude or try to defame anyone… you’re going to be blocked and your comments are going to be deleted.” 

 

No examples of the material were given, which means it's possibly there was some vile, threatening speech that was rightly removed. But given our experience, we think it more likely someone sounded off, and the Council simply feels it doesn't need to listen. 😬

 

That's why we've contacted the Council, seeking clarification around what criteria they use to establish whether someone is being racist (as this work could be used by some to simply mean 'they disagree with us'). We also reminded them we've had some considerable success in fighting local councils, and that while we'd rather not, we're ready to hold them accountable if we have to. We listed off the Councils we've challenged - it's turning into a fair list: Auckland City Council, Taupo District Council, Rotorua Lakes District Council, Palmerston North City Council, Wellington City Council, Blenheim District Council, Christchurch City Council, and others! 🙌

 

 

5. Submissions: Media regulations and Political Neutrality 

  

Our team is consistently working on submissions and engagement with public consultations to make sure there's someone making the case for your speech rights every step of the way. This week, we've released two more submissions:  

 

 

6. University apologises - more work with students ahead  🙌

 

Earlier this month, our team spent 3 days on campus at University of Auckland's O-week, talking with thousands of students (we signed nearly 1,200 up to our database, to hear more about our work!).  

 

Unfortunately, Auckland was the only university that let us come - the other 7 all said no (or more precisely, didn't even reply to our numerous emails/calls to try and get a pass).  

 

When we revealed this on social media, a lot of our supporters were furious these universities didn't even reply. To AUT's credit, they have come back to us, apologised, and welcomed us to work with their students in the future.

 

 

 

We're not going to win all these fights at once, but it shows - step by step, we'll get there. 2 down, 6 to go.  

 

There's still lots more to talk about - interviews of James Lindsay's tour with us, the book club we'll be running next month, and a whole new merchandise line so you can get your own Free Speech Union 'gang patch' tee-shirt. But we'll save that for next week.  

 

*** 

 

In short, there's a lot happening in the fight for free speech. Thanks for your support.

 

P.S. We’re going into our last week before the end of our financial year - if each supporter contributed just a small amount to our fight, we’d be able to do much more. 🙏

 

Would you chip in $7 to keep speech free in New Zealand, so we can keep up the fight over the next 12 months?

 

Donate here now